It feels like we’ve waited a long time for the new Mac Pro, and in fact, we have. However, in typical Apple fashion they blew away expectations with the new Mac Pro and Apple Pro Display XDR.
I had a chance to see the Mac Pro in action after the keynote in a music studio setting and it was incredible. I saw a Pro Tools and Logic setup, both running hundreds of tracks, with plug-ins running, while playing video, and everything worked seamlessly.
Mac Pro isn’t just an upgraded pro machine, it is completely redone to maximize performance in every aspect of the computer. As Phil Schiller said, it has “extreme performance.”
“We designed Mac Pro for users who require a modular system with extreme performance, expansion and configurability. With its powerful Xeon processors, massive memory capacity, groundbreaking GPU architecture, PCIe expansion, Afterburner accelerator card and jaw-dropping design, the new Mac Pro is a monster that will enable pros to do their life’s best work,” said Phil Schiller, Apple’s senior vice president of Worldwide Marketing.
If you’re like me, you noticed the similarity with the “cheese grater” Mac Pro of years ago, and for good reason. Both machines are similar in the exterior look, and why not, that was a pro machine that worked.
Mac Pro features Xeon processors up to 28 cores and 12 DIMM slots, allowing for up to 1.5TB of memory.
This type of power allows projects that normally took multiple machines to power to be done on one Mac Pro. The music projects I mentioned earlier were done on multiple machines until the new Mac Pro, when they were consolidated into one project, running on one machine.
As if the introduction of the Radeon Pro Vega II wasn’t enough, Apple also introduced the Radeon Pro Vega II Duo, and the Mac Pro will allow you to run two of them.
With the addition of Apple’s Afterburner accelerator card, the Mac Pro can decode up to 6.3 billion pixels per second. This setup will virtually eliminate proxy workflows, allowing editors to use native formats directly from the camera.
I expected a lot from the new Mac Pro and even I was blown away with what Apple came up with in the Mac Pro.
Of course the devil is in the details, but it sure looks like they hit it out of the park. Even if the SSD isn’t replaceable, you can connect an external drive and have it be plenty fast.
At my previous job in a physics research lab we used a cheese grater Mac Pro that we loaded up with a 12-core processor and 64 Gb RAM to run numerical modeling simulations. This new machine would have been an awesome successor.
Mac expandability and future-proofing has a much higher price tag than it used to.
“This new machine would have been an awesome successor.”
Not too late. It can still be.
This isn’t designed for those making Youtube videos
I well understand which relatively few and rarefied professions this machine was designed for, thank you.
I’m looking farther back than 2013. My comment was about the fact that, for years, such specifically expandable Macs were affordable by a much wider range of professional workers.
If I still worked there, yes. ?
I agree these prices remind me of the Quadra days. I want one, but not sure if I can afford it. I guess it depends on the kind of work that comes my way.
The tech specs page shows that it has two slots for SSD cards, and you can populate only one or both. So yes, storage can be upgraded. Proprietary Apple storage, since it uses their T2 chip, but maybe OWC will reverse engineer it.
Yep, that’s the problem. Apple doesn’t make an upgradeable machine for anyone unwilling to spend less than $6,000. They used to.
All of the customers who used to buy those old inexpensive Mac Pros buy macbooks now.
The market for desktops has shrunk so much that Apple has all but given up on making desktops for ordinary people – the new Mini is for pros on a small budget, the new Mac pro is for pros with a very high budget, and the various kinds of Imac are for everyone else who is still crazy enough to need/want a desktop instead of a laptop.
People who want affordable, modular, and upgradable? Apple no longer makes anything for them.
Apparently.
“Crazy enough,” indeed. No judgment here, I see.
Couldn’t one just throw an NVMe drive on a PCI card or two for extra fast storage? That’s the beauty of a Mac that has PCI slots!
And they stopped because about 5% of their customers ever upgraded components and most who did simply added RAM and/or put in more storage. People also started to move to laptops in increasing numbers.
VERY few non-Pro folks added cards etc but allowing those slots added to product cost. So we got the iMac.
I kind of wish I could upgrade the RAM and SSD in my MBP even if it was a service center thing… but I can’t, so eh.
The 2009 Mac Pro would be $4000 in today’s dollars (8 core version). So, yeah, the new machine is appreciably more expensive if we want to assume it’s roughly the performance equivalent of the 09 machine for the market… but let’s not pretend you used to be able to buy Pro performance (whatever that meant at the time a machine was released) for really cheap.
I can think of at least one other regular commenter here who’ll have some very helpful advice to address that “affordable” problem, for both of us. 😉
Lots of whinging and whining on the cost of this workstation. I don’t need one but some people do.
Going to Dell or HP and you can quickly spec out something around 50K. And then you have to buy a display. 😉
The Pros (including me) whined & Apple finally delivered a Pro machine worthy of the name. So, am I satisfied with the results?
Largely, yes. Apple certainly blew my mind while watching the reveal today. I could have appreciated a less-expensive, middle-ground machine somewhere between the iMac Pro and this. I’m happy they brought back the individual display, but wow, the XDR is borderline
outrageousheart-stopping.One concern I have is how small the native UI will become on that 6K XDR. I’m not a big fan of displays larger than 27″/2k, mostly because everything becomes super small in ‘Default’ and the ‘Scaled’ alternatives are just not “sharp”. Maybe Apple has or will optimize Catalina to keep the UI scaled at a comfortable size.
Overall, big exhale.
I class myself among the crazy ones who still want a desktop.
But we are dinosaurs. Apple doesn’t make computers for us anymore, they’re only interested in making computing boxes for people who don’t care what’s inside those boxes as long as it lets them get their work done.
The extra $2000 over the old tower MP goes to:
-t2 security chip.
-double the PCI-e slots.
-a considerably beefier baseline graphics card.
-some other tech specs I have missed
-new vacation cottages for all Apple executives and shareholders.
But I think the baseline model is there just to make people angry on the Internet. The target market for this computer is going to buy the maxed out version and be happy to do so.
The whining comes because Apple doesn’t sell a machine that many people want. And that’s a reasonably priced, reasonably powerful machine that can at least have its storage and RAM upgraded easily and without voiding the warranty.
Not that long ago, nearly every Apple offered at this this minimal degree of upgradeability: Power Mac/Mac Pro, iMac, Mac mini, MacBook Pro could all have RAM upgraded. Depending on the model, upgrading storage was trickier, but not impossible.
So the complaints are that Apple no longer sells a machine that meets the needs or wants of many computer users, and the defense for Apple is “The Mac Pro isn’t for you,” which of course is precisely the complaint!
The Mac mini is the worst offender. Many people, including myself, hoped it would be the desktop computer for those who don’t want an all-in-one, who want better price/performance than a MacBook Pro can offer, who want good graphics performance, and who want to be able to upgrade RAM and internal storage ourselves, but don’t need a $6,000 plus machine (of course you can add external storage, and even external GPU, but at that point, it’s no longer mini in size and certainly not in price, so what’s the point?).
The MacBook Pro is also an offender. On the one hand, it’s an understandable tradeoff in terms of size and weight vs performance and upgradeability. On the other hand, it’s thinness also means it throttles under full load, so you can’t always get the performance you pay for (not to mention the compromises in keyboard design in pursuit of thinness).
This is important because if, as people legitimately point out, most people have moved from desktops to laptops so the MacBook Pro serves the mainstream purposes that Power Macs, Mac Pros, Mac minis, etc. used to serve, then we’re right to want a MacBook Pro that has at least some of the upgradeability that Apple desktops used to offer. And if that MacBook Pro is spending most of its time sitting on a desk, and some small amount of time shuttling between home and office, then we can accept a laptop that is slightly heavier and slightly thicker in trade for better upgradeability and sustained performance.
In short, Apple doesn’t offer the computers that a lot of customers—who may be “pros” at something other than 4K and 8K video editing—want. We might be whining, but we’ve got legitimate reasons to complain.
RAM usage has been largely stable for several years. What is the use case that would require a RAM upgrade today?
If Apple charged reasonable prices for RAMs, it’d be less of a big deal. But Apple charges $400 to upgrade an MBP to 32GB, where as even high end 32GB RAM (2 x 16GB) costs half the upgrade cost or less.
So it’d be nice to buy the base RAM and upgrade at a more reasonable price. Or upgrade at a later date if you find the base RAM wasn’t sufficient for your uses. Or if your uses change. Or a year or two down the road when RAM prices have come down (as they generally tend to do).
Upgrading RAM has been a relatively inexpensive way to improve the performance and extend the useful life of a computer. Which is part of the reason Apple makes it difficult or impossible to do it yourself (the other big reason is obsession with thinness); they’d rather you buy a brand new computer, or load it up with expensive RAM when you buy it.
I love it, but don’t love the price. Just for comparison sake, the latest version of the Cheese Grater MacPro was pretty state of the art at the time, but didn’t cost as much as this one does… not that its not worth it, but this is almost a doubling in cost for the base model. With that said, don’t be surprised if Apple introduces a MacPro Mini in a year or two. Based on the same design, but cheaper. That’s the one I want!!!
I was impressed to see “you know, this x16 PCIE slot needs MORE LANES, so we’re just gonna add a set”. Twice.
OTOH, every desktop Mac is “expandable” now, apart from the 21″ iMac [IIRC] with soldered memory.
Thunderbolt 3 is a 40Gb/s access pipe to whatever you want to hang off the machine.
Yes, with more external hookups and power cables. I can see them all right now, and I don’t have T3.
Personally, I would love something slightly bumped from the baseline model. But I can’t afford it.
Which is fine, as I don’t really need it.
What does “upgradeable” mean?
Apple NEVER supported CPU upgrades, that I recall (third parties did, and hell, I’ve put in a new Core2 CPU in an old Mini).
(And as a guy who builds his own gaming PCs, I assure you I … don’t really ever want to put a new CPU on a legacy motherboard anyway. That’s a sucker bet.)
RAM’s upgradeable now in the Mini and the big iMac [and people buying laptops sure seem to prefer “small, light, and sealed” to “can easily pop in another stick].
And like I said above, if you need more storage? That’s what the TB3 port is for.
“Inside the case” doesn’t matter much with that kind of bandwidth via a cable.
“And that’s a reasonably priced, reasonably powerful machine that can at
least have its storage and RAM upgraded easily and without voiding the
warranty.”
RAM, well, 27″ iMac and the new Mini. Both upgradeable RAM, yes?
Storage? I repeat, it’s 2019.
If USB3 isn’t fast enough for you (“not most people”), that’s what the TB3 functionality is for.
(I have an older Mini, and a Drobo RAID unit on USB3, for a home media server.
It’s plenty fast enough; faster than the network I use to connect to it.)
Adjusted for inflation the 2009 Pro would be $4000. Not $6k, but not drastically cheap either.
Wow, that’s a lot to read into that comment. I get where you’re coming from because I am loath to give up my current 2015 MacBook Pro – it can be frustrating.
Maybe I should have written “the cost of THIS WORKSTATION”. I wasn’t thinking about other lines like desktops and/or laptops.
There aren’t as many of you hobbyists as you think there are. Mass market consumers are fine with laptops, iMacs, and the Mini. On the large iMac and the Mini you can have more RAM installed. Storage? Meh. Get a bunch. Add external if you need it later. You won’t be changing the video cards and that’s more useful IMO.
So it’s not really a big deal. Only the tinkerer hobbyist is upset. Not Apple’s target market.
The world moved on. Today’s iMacs are amazingly productive for most people. I’m on a maxed out 2011. Let that sink in
I would love it if Apple were to introduce a MacPro Mini in a year or two, but I would be very, very surprised if they did.
None of what you say has any bearing on a Mac Pro which by definition is a very niche, very high end machine. Whining about the Pro because Apple doesn’t make a consumer level box with expandability is nonsensical. The Pro isn’t expensive because it’s expandable… it’s expensive because it’s a no holds barred machine where everything in the box and that can be added is designed for performance first, not affordability.
Also, see my above comment – there’s a small contingent that wants what you’re talking about (under 5-10% of the users ever add a card etc) so it makes no sense to incur the overhead of expansion slots etc when so few people in percentage terms) every really use them. It also restricts their design capabilities to allow it.
I do agree that being able to replace RAM would be nice. But at this point its VERY clear that Apple isn’t going to do that in their laptops, so…
Not to mention the stratification of computer-user categories.
Apple’s had Retina for a number of years, so I’m sure you can run the display like that…
But they really need to make the UI scalable in a sensible way soon.
Yeah, I have a not-that-maxed 2015 27″ with the i5, and it’s just fine.
(Because I realized I don’t actually need to spend the extra on hyperthreading and an i7 there.
I do that on my gaming/work PC.)
Yeah, I have a not-that-maxed 2015 27″ with the i5, and it’s just fine.
(Because I realized I don’t actually need to spend the extra on hyperthreading and an i7 there.
I do that on my gaming/work PC.)
I’d also note that the Mini doesn’t have a video card, though you can add an external via TB3. It uses the same cpu-integrated graphics as most of the laptops.
Which is surprisingly good, honestly, compared to the Old Days.
(The recent iMacs seem to have a soldered GPU, which makes sense for the form factor and the way nobody ever really replaced the modular ones.
But equally … can drop in an external one via Thunderbolt, if you really, really, really care.)
I think there was a long period of time when scalability just wasn’t going to happen because it would have required too much work from application developers. I think they’ve chipped away at that enough that it is probably viable (not to mention necessary) now.
It’s interesting how prices went down for many years not just in relative terms but even absolute $ terms (without taking into account inflation, I mean). But inflation had to win eventually. (Damnit.)
My experience was that prices on Apple towers held relatively steady for some years. I believe I went through about three or four of them at roughly similar cost (minus post-purchase upgrades).
I think the macOS UI has been ‘optimized’ for each device.
When I use a third-party display, say 2k/23.4″, the UI looks too small at Default for any reasonable working.
Apple once aimed to adopt resolution independence for OS X, but the feature never shipped. With the variety of resolutions available on screens, it’s time for this to be added.