Jony Ive’s mistakes: When beautiful design is bad design

Charles Arthur:

All of the plaudits for Jony Ive begin with how he and Steve Jobs saved Apple with the iMac. No doubt about it: that instantly recognizable shape became an icon, and led to thousands of imitations using translucent colored plastic, often in that same Bondi Blue, to show that they were part of the late-90s vibe. In a sense, the iMac was a triumph of packaging: the components inside were pretty straightforward. If Apple had put them into a beige box, the company would now be a historical footnote.

And:

The quote often attributed to Einstein is “everything must be made as simple as possible, but not one bit simpler.” I think the trouble was that Ive often ignored the second part of that advice in the pursuit of refinement.

This is actually a fair take on Jony Ive designs that are considered by many to be mistakes, triumphs of form over function.

My favorite part is the section called “The strength of compromise”, which highlights things gone right, compromises that yielded greatness.

Terrific read, all around.