Interesting snippet from this TechCrunch post:
Buried in Apple’s latest range of MacBooks — including the MacBook Pro out earlier this year and the just-announced MacBook Air — is the new T2 security chip, which helps protect the device’s encryption keys, storage, fingerprint data and secure boot features.
Little was known about the chip until today. According to its newest published security guide, the chip comes with a hardware microphone disconnect feature that physically cuts the device’s microphone from the rest of the hardware whenever the lid is closed.
And from the T2 Security Chip Overview itself:
All Mac portables with the Apple T2 Security Chip feature a hardware disconnect that ensures that the microphone is disabled whenever the lid
is closed. This disconnect is implemented in hardware alone, and therefore prevents any software, even with root or kernel privileges in macOS, and even the software on the T2 chip, from engaging the microphone when the lid is closed. (The camera is not disconnected in hardware because its field of view is completely obstructed with the lid closed.)
Good to know.
I never thought of this before, but it seems like something that people would have been justified in assuming happened all along. Good move by Apple.
Why not physycally disconnecting the webcam when not using app with approved credential ?
Because “approved credential” is something that only software can determine, and thus is subject to software attacks*.
“For everything, period, whenever the lid is closed” is something you can hardcode into unmodifiable parts of the T2 chip, with wiring to the lid sensor and mic controller/unit, and thus cannot be attacked in software.
(* Approved? That also packs in a lot of assumptions as to who approves, how often/when, etc.
And you have to store the approval somewhere, and ensure malware can’t modify/overwrite/hijack/spoof that…
Better to just have a hardware-level “active” light to let you see if it’s on, so you can notice if it shouldn’t be, honestly.)
Make sense !
“the chip comes with a hardware microphone disconnect feature that physically cuts the device’s microphone from the rest of the hardware whenever the lid is closed”
Note that while it’s in hardware, it does not “physically” cut the mic off from the rest of the hardware. Because the T2 chip does not include a tiny relay that “physically” disconnects it.
Hardware-level and thus immune to software and even firmware attacks, sure. Physical, no.
It’s basically going to just be “keeping the transistor that powers it and/or connects it to the USB bus off”.
This is a great move but like the hardware interlock on the Macbook camera, nothing is unhackable.
The hardware light would be a lot more useful if Apple’s apps like Photo Booth and FaceTime let go of the camera when in the background.
I have no idea if Apple has achieved “unhackable” with this design, but your stance is a very negative one. From there, it’s a single step to “…so why bother trying?”
Things can absolutely be made unhackable. My office light switch, for instance, is totally unhackable. It’s a simple throw switch.
Makes sense; I never use either so never would have noticed that.
You mean aside from when I said, “this is a great move”. Lots of the commentary on the web make it sound like they solved the issue. What would be interesting is to do a pure physical disconnect of the microphone when the lid closes, so there is no way to hack it. Like literally flipping a mechanical disconnect switch.
This is a feature I wouldn’t mind seeing other OEMs try to copy in some form.
Anything that’s pure hardware and not updateable via software or controllable from outside the chip somehow is “unhackable”.
It’s not even all that HARD to manage “unhackable” for things like this; it’s just that most hardware makers would never bother to try, or care.
I can see why that might have been unclear! I was referring to only the “nothing is unhackable” bit. Lots of things are unhackable, and it’s worth the effort.