In the embedded video, Serenity Caldwell used the iPad Pro and the Surface Book (same screen as the Surface Pro 4) to do some similar sketching tasks using built in tools, all with informative running commentary.
Later in the video, Serenity switches the Surface Book to desktop mode and uses the tablet to draw with the Photoshop. Next, she moves to the iPad Pro, using Photoshop’s iOS tools (pieces of the full Photoshop, all designed to create content, which you then share using Creative Cloud).
To my untrained eye, the iPad Pro seems much more responsive, the Apple Pencil more precise. As you watch the video, watch as Serenity pinches to shrink her drawings. The iPad Pro seems to respond immediately, while the Surface Book seems to do a bit of thinking first. This could be the video, but it does seem consistent throughout the video. And, of course, Serenity’s comments about the precision of the Surface stylus support this notion.
On the other hand, consider that the Surface Book has access to the full version of Photoshop, while the iPad Pro uses lighter weight apps specifically designed for iOS, all designed to share back to the cloud and/or your Mac.
Be sure to take a look at this video as well, where Serenity uses Astropad to connect her iPad Pro to her computer, emulating a Wacom Cintiq tablet.
Even though my Surfacebook 4 is a POS, it does amaze me we’re having these videos and that the results are close enough to need to analyze them. It means Microsoft is doing something right… and those I know that like their Surfacebooks are the kinds that say “its better than paper” – if thats your point of reference its no wonder.
C’mon Serenity – you’re a lefty and positioned the camera over your LEFT shoulder, thereby making it impossible to visually gauge responsiveness of the stylus/screen combo? How hard would it have been to position the camera so viewers could actually SEE what’s going on?
Something right? I think it’d be better to say that Microsoft is attempting to solve the same problem through a radically different tact.
Over time, we’ll find out which approach will win.
The problem is not the Surface but MS pricing – MS refuses to accept that thanks to their 2-decade long mismangaement of WINDOWS, WIN pricing is maxed out at 35% the pricing of an Apple product so as noted, last Q, Surface sales are already dropping or peaked.
That video is really limited by the horrible camera angle. She’s drawing leftie, the camera needed to be on her right shoulder instead.
She also gives the Surface much more credit than it deserves IMO. You can see the stylus on the Surface missing the input entirely but she says it’s “good.”???
Your comment seems like just a wild guess to me. Correlation is not causality.
TheAustralian also did a similar test.
SurfaceBook comes out much worse in that video.
The illustrator says to the SurfaceBook drawn version as
“a baby drew it”.
That is the worse comment ever can be made.
Plus the illustrator didn’t know ipad version of photoshop at all.
Still 3 weeks until the Pencil arrives. Pity.