The Apple Watch bet

It is on.

Kirk McElhearn wrote up his take on the pricing of the Apple Watch line here.

The Apple Watch Edition is not a luxury watch; it’s just a gold-cased version of the cheaper watch. There’s nothing exclusive about it, nothing special. It’s not like more expensive watches where you pay for complex machinery. Yes, there is gold; that will make it more expensive than the other models. But not that much. Estimates of the cost of the gold suggest that the metal would cost less than $1,000.

As such, I think the list price for the base model Apple Watch Edition will be $1,999. There will certainly be a price differential by size, and it could be a couple hundred dollars for this version. In addition, the watchbands will cost as much as several hundred dollars. There’s just no reason to pay more. I repeat, this is not a luxury watch; this is a smartwatch with a gold case.

My predictions are here.

The consensus seems to be that the high end iPhone 6 costs about $247 to make, including parts and labor. Without a contract, that same iPhone 6 sells for $849. That’s a price/cost ratio of about 3.44 (the price of the phone is a bit more than 3 times the cost).

Apply that same model to the Apple Watch, and you get a price ranging from $3,400 to $6,800.

The terms of the bet? Kirk wins if the price of the highest end Apple Watch Edition is US$2500 or less. One penny more than that and I win.

The stakes? If I win, Kirk sends me a large packet of digestive biscuits from the UK. If he wins, I send him this.

Get ready to pay up, Kirk!



54 thoughts on “The Apple Watch bet”

  1. BOB!!!!! Long time, no see, my friend. I can smell those digestive biscuits already. 🙂

  2. You will win this bet. A solid 18k gold watch would be impossible to sell for $2000.

  3. I’m on Kirk’s side with the logic. Nothing special about the Apple Watch Edition. But, Apple’s pricing is not always logical (se: MacBook “Black” tax) so I’m guessing Dave will win.

  4. Is there something special about a gold Rolex vs. it’s non-gold counterpart outside of the gold? Do gold Rolexes have more complex machinery or craftsmanship?

    Quite honestly if the gold Watch offered functionality that the other models didn’t then I would worry as that would signal Apple’s products are no longer for everyone. Why do people who most likely have zero interest/means in owning the gold watch care whether it’s special (outside of the gold)? Why does it matter to you?

  5. Sorry, but Ars Technica just uncovered an Apple patent that suggests you will owe Kirk a can of fluff.
    http://arstechnica.com/apple/2015/03/is-apples-real-watch-innovation-a-gold-case-thats-as-tough-as-steel/

    The article focuses on toughness, but that’s not the real story. From section 0034 of the patent: “Moreover, since the density of 18 k gMMC is less
    than a 18 k metal-based gold alloy, the amount of gold used in the 18 k
    gMMC is less than that used in a 18 k metal-based gold alloy.”
    http://appft1.uspto.gov/netacgi/nph-Parser?Sect1=PTO1&Sect2=HITOFF&d=PG01&p=1&u=/netahtml/PTO/srchnum.html&r=1&f=G&l=50&s1=20140361670.PGNR.

    That means Apple’s 18k gold could, and probably does, have less gold by mass than everyone else’s 18k gold, which means all estimates of the Apple Watch Edition’s gold content are high. It could be shockingly cheap.

  6. There’s nothing special other than the gold. And solid gold is expensive. Maybe if it’s the leather band and just the watch case itself it could eek down to $2500, but I think that’s stretching it.

  7. Yes, gold Rolex’s have a different design aesthetic. They don’t just change materials, they change the design to show off the gold. Take a look, none of them are just a different color. http://www.rolex.com/watches/find-rolex.html

    No, gold Rolex’s probably don’t have more complex workings. They probably don’t have much more complex workings than a Timex.

    Different iPhones have different features, it would not be unusual for the watches.

    I actually have zero interest in any Watch, Edition or otherwise. But I’m a fan of Apple and their products and I like to discuss them the way others talk about sports, politics or Game of Thrones.

  8. I guessed this might be the case as was told I didn’t know what I was talking about. Nice to be vindicated.

  9. Saying there is nothing special about the watch other than the gold is like saying there is nothing special about the rich, other than the money. Might be true, but irrelevant.

  10. It seems like Apple intentionally worked in this period between the announcement of the product and the announcement of the pricing in order to calibrate people’s expectations with regard to price. I don’t think for a second that Apple is going to announce a $20,000 watch as some people have apparently predicted with a straight face. But let’s say the price is actually $2,500. If they had released that info a few weeks ago, the press would’ve been going out of their minds saying how out of touch Apple was to release something so expensive. But at this point many people will actually think it’s very reasonable.

  11. Yes. $2000 is impossible. But how many gold watches of that size go for only $4k?

  12. The volume of gold Apple’s patent allows them to use in rose or yellow 18k gold is less than half that of a conventional metal alloy 18k gold. That cuts the cost in half. For Dave to be right about the price, he has to be wrong about the 3.44 cost/price ratio.

  13. I admit, I did not see how that was possible either. The mass/volume loophole never occurred to me, but once again it seems Apple is defying conventional wisdom.

  14. The $4000-4500 range sounds like a reasonable bet, even ignoring all the gold-weighing etc.

    It is the price range in which you can find some third-tier gold watches (with leather or rubber bands) today. And that is a reasonable tier for Apple to target. They certainly do not play in tier one (Patek Philipe, Breguet and some speciality brands), never will. No electronic gizmo will make tier two either. The Rolexes, Omegas and Breitlings of this world are worn for decades and passed between generations. They can ask $15k and up for a gold model because of that. An Apple Watch may be ‘current enough’ for maybe 5 years… and that’s optimistic.

    You do not price a mass market product, and even the Edition is a mass market product, into a price range only Sheiks and spoiled kids with billionaire parents can afford. These people are not Apple’s customer base. I think it was Gruber who pointed out the ‘affordable luxury’ aspect of Apple, and I believe he is correct there. Even if Apple downplays sales expectations, they do not go for a complete niche market. How many golden Rolexes get bought every year? They sell around 600k watches total annually and certainly 90% of them are steel or bicolor.

  15. Dave will be enjoying those biscuits, guaranteed. This $2500 dollar guess is based on – once again, I might add – the desperately flawed assumption that the Watch will be prices like other standard consumer electronics.

    Repeat after me: The prices of personal luxury products have NOTHING to do with cost of materials. At all.

    Look. My favourite watch is an Omega Speedster, stainless steel case and bracelet. Wonderful device – 59 years old now and you could still time your space mission by it. If I wanted to replace it today (item number 331.10.42.51.02.002 for those playing along at home) it would a titch over $6K. Fair enough. BUT … if for some reason I lost my mind and wanted to get the rose gold version (item number 331.53.42.51.02.002)? That would set me back TWENTY-ONE THOUSAND BUCKS. That is a $15,000 dollar boost for one thing – the gold case. The mechanicals of the watch – the movement, the face, EVERYTHING – are exactly the same, only the case has changed. And for that privilege, you are going to drop an additional cost that is more than what you would pay for a serviceable car.

    BTW: That is the gold watch with a leather bracelet. Want the gold bracelet to match (331.50.42.51.02.002)? Tack on another $7K – more than a $20,000 boost from the same device in stainless. Better make that TWO boxes of biscuits for being so amazingly wrong.

    Also BTW: The Apple stainless clasp bracelet looks to be MUCH nicer than the standard Omega bracelet. If you have to replace the one on your Omega it is going to cost you $600. Food for thought when pondering what the bracelet options on the standard Apple Watch are going to run you …

  16. Again, compare the Omega Speedster in stainless and gold (I listed the item numbers above). There is NO difference at all besides the case material – the design is literally identical (and yes, I mean literally). But you will play 15K more for the gold version.

    That said, a Rolex or (better) Omega have VASTLY more complex workings than a Timex. AND those workings are hand machined by insanely skilled craftsmen. Comparing high-end watches to a department store item is silly. But comparing high-end watches to the Apple Watch? that is entirely apropos.

  17. Kirk’s logic only makes sense if you don’t know how high-end personal goods are priced. His logic is rubbish if you actually know what this market is all about.

    Free biscuits!!!!

  18. I think Apple wants to make premium products available to more people, so they won’t mark up the gold content in the same way the Swiss watch makers do. That said, there’s no way Kirk wins this bet.

    FWIW , my guess is the gold Watch starts at $4999 for the 38mm version with elastomer band. If Apple introduces a solid gold link bracelet, then we’ll see the price hit five digits for some configurations.

    The real kicker will be if they take the environmentally friendly, non-disposable route and offer “servicing” for their gold watches. $799 to upgrade all the electronics (screen, battery, processor, sensors, etc.) will still give them massive profit margins. More importantly, it would help sell many more $5k+ watches.

  19. The logic isn’t bad but he seems to discount the technology. Say the gold content is $800… then you have to manufacture that gold into a case. Then you have to make the electronics. Then you need to assemble everything, add packaging, etc.

    His logic seems to be related the cost of the gold and nothing else. If the gold cost is $800 and machining it, assembling it and adding the strap is $200 and the electronics are $200 we’re at $1200 in raw costs. That doesn’t cover support, recouping the development costs, etc… but hey, let’s triple that (following the iPhone model) and you’re at $3600.

    Before anyone says “but… even at 50% margin…” note that you don’t base such calculations on the raw cost of goods, but on the fully weighted cost. 3X manufacturing cost is actually kind of low.

  20. Yes! I don’t think we’ll see $2,500, but $4,999 will look reasonable after all these $10k speculations.

  21. The interesting thing about the pricing argument on the Gold watches to me, is whether or not Apple does something new and adds extra dollars to the price simply for “prestige” reasons like the Rolex.

    The sad truth about Rolexes, is that while they are good watches, you are paying literally thousands of dollars OVER AND ABOVE the materials costs, the manufacturing costs, and a huge healthy profit margin. In other words, when you pay for one of those $10,000-$20,000 watches, you are paying mostly for prestige only.

    In the parlance of the 1950’s … you are being “swindled.”

    I’m with those that say that the watch will be expensive, but that the price will relate at least superficially to the costs, and that even with Apple famous super-extra-double-fat margins, that they won’t also simply add on thousands and thousands “extra” just for prestige.

    I’m not sure I would even like Apple anymore i they went that route. Swindling people is generally considered a bad thing.

  22. But his argument is that Apple will price the thing the way they price all of their things, and this is a new market for Apple.

    Logically, there is a 50/50 chance that upon entering this new market, Apple will either bring it’s pricing model with it, or adopt the new one.

    Since their old model is (reasonably) “fair” and the new one (for high-end personal goods), is actually kind of a rip-off, it’s reasonable to argue that they will stick with their own method of pricing.

    We shall find out soon enough.

  23. Fluff. It’s the best stuff. Sorry to say that Kirk is going to lose the bet and more importantly the Fluff.

  24. If it’s solid gold, I’d be more on a higher price, but since there’s no where near the amount of work building an Apple Watch compared to a high end watch (despite significantly more functionality), I’d wager lower pricing and gold plating. Plus, additional functionality of future Apple Watch models will make existing one’s obsolete.

    Personally, at the prices Dave is suggesting, I’d much rather have a Nomos ‘Metro’ or Nomos ‘Tangente’.

    http://www.nomos-store.com/en/Watches/Model-series/Metro/
    http://www.nomos-store.com/en/Watches/Model-series/Tangente/

    Plus they have more of an industrial design I think Jony Ive was hoping to design. (Yet, one has to consider the display space needed for a smart watch.) Unfortunately, the Apple Watch seems more like a design from the early 1980s and I’d gather will see a redesign at some point.

  25. His logic is based on the cost of gold because that’s the only variable among the different models. For all the other models you still “have to manufacture that [material] into a case. Then you have to make the electronics. Then you need to assemble everything, add packaging, etc.”

  26. Apple has had crazy “low” prices for stuff before. Remember when everyone was sure the Apple Tablet would start at $1000.

    Half the reason that a gold Rolex sells for what it does is because of the brand name. Sure Apple has a name also but they might decide that they would rather go volume than go clout

  27. to me the more important bet will be how much of this tech turns up in the next iPhone and iPad.

    taptic engine rather than spinning vibe motor
    encased chip to protect it from the elements (wet logic board is a major reason for dead phones)
    Force Touch providing a level of pressure sensitivity for drawing etc.

    and so on

  28. The prices of personal luxury products have NOTHING to do with cost of materials. At all.

    But really, when it comes to Apple. that is a mistake that almost all pundits make routinely regarding anything Apple makes. I can do a calculation on how valuable dirt is and it means nothing to a retailer that has to source, measure, package, ship and sell dirt.

    I’m not saying the quoted statement in wrong. It’s just that iFixit (for eg) and like minded tech oriented types routinely invoke the cost of raw materials and basic components as if Apple was selling a kit for a phone you had to assemble and program yourself. The tech press seem incapable of recognizing that a complete, functional device can be and sometimes is significantly more valuable than the sum of it’s parts, never mind how much of a price buffer there can be for an actual luxury item.

  29. Gold introduces several variables besides the cost of the gold itself. You have to hire security at every step of your supply chain from the case manufacturer through final assembly to the retail store. You have to transport the goods by bonded courier and not UPS or fedex. You have to pay the people making the cases and assembling the watches enough that they aren’t going to be tempted to steal them (so foxconn is probably out).

    Plus, gold is a commodity whose prices yo-yo with the market. You can’t calculate the cost of the gold based on the market price, you have to include a generous allowance for market fluctuations — otherwise if the stock market gets in a tizzy and people start buying more gold, the price goes up and suddenly you’re selling every watch at a loss.

    There are several factors beyond “x ounces of gold at $y an ounce” to factor into the price of a gold watch.

  30. I worked in the jewelry business a long time ago, but I think the retail model is still the same. Gold jewelry has a 3X markup. An item a retailer pays $1000 for sells for $3000. I don’t think Apple will undercut the retail standard on gold jewelry. Where they’ll innovate is by allowing a gold Apple Watch owner to update their electronics by having a replaceable “movement.” So when you get a new iPhone you can also get a “new” Apple Watch, in terms of the technology, for the cost of the “movement” ($350, maybe lower since you won’t need a new case).

  31. there’s also nothing more special about a gold Rolex submariner over the steel, except gold — yet the price doesn’t reflect that. thus Kirk’s stance is wrong. people pay premium prices for he privilege of doing so.

  32. according to watch geeks on other sites, no, there is no difference. certainly not any functional difference. just a different metal.

  33. Free biscuits. You should make it so the he has to send you one biscuit per dollar above $2500. You’d get about 7,500 biscuits.

  34. “They probably don’t have much more
    complex workings than a Timex. “

    Timex are made my a machine.

    Rolex are made by hand. hundreds of moving parts make up a Rolex. Timex has maybe a dozen.

    Timex (quartz) “tick” once a second. Rolex “tick” 5 times a second.

    A mechanical movement often has jewel bearings because they offer less resistance (therefore less wear and tear on the cogs and gears).

    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jewel_bearing

    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Automatic_watch#Watch_winders

    If you buy a decent mechanical watch you should think about getting a watch winder.. a little case you keep the watch in that rotates it to keep it wound (mechanicals stop working after about 36-48 hours if you don’t wind or wear it – natural arm motion winds a auto-mechanical)

    your winder needs to be set to the specific movement in your watch.. anywhere from 600 to 1200 revolutions per day counter or clockwise (or either) depending on the movement. incorrect winder settings could damage your watch.

    Orbita makes high end winders.. here are the various settings for Omega:

    http://www.orbita.com/database-search/?search=omega

  35. I really don’t get why folks want the Apple Watch Edition to be so expensive. There seems to be a battle among bloggers to set expectations each higher than the next so that everyone will be “surprised” when it comes in a much more reasonable price (a la the original iPad). I personally think it will be around $2-3k mainly based on materials and then Apple’s standard profit margin. A big part of the reason a fancy watch costs so much is the mechanical and intricate nature of it. As far as Apple has told us so far the insides of each watch are identical. If you sold me a Rolex with Timex inside it would not fetch Rolex prices. And if there is no upgrade path, I just think the market for something, much more expense quickly dries up.

  36. If I’m honest, I just don’t want Apple to be selling true luxury goods (as opposed to the computer industry version of luxury goods), as it doesn’t really jibe with my image of the company, or myself as one of their customers. (And I also think it will only reinforce the idea that some have that Apple users have more money than sense.)

    With the exception of something like the 20th Anniversary Macintosh, Apple products have always been something that anyone could aspire to own. The rich and powerful had pretty much the same computers that the average guy in a coffeeshop had. And while I suppose you could argue that there won’t be any functional differences between the watch models, I still feel like they’re going down a different path than the one they’ve been following up until now.

  37. Kirk wins if the price of the highest end Apple Watch Edition is US$2500 or less. One penny more than that and I win.

    I imagine Tim Cook being a Loop fan, initially planning to release it for 2499, then going “Let’s add a dollar and a penny to that price”.

  38. I agree with Kirk, Apple is more interested in expanding its ecosystem, not competing with high end watch manufacturers.

    If someone spends $10k-$20k on a watch they won’t be interested in replacing it any time soon, no matter how much they can afford it. That doesn’t fit with Apple, they want their consumers on regular upgrade cycles so they can keep pushing the technological envelope.

    I have no idea how they’ll get the price that low for the gold edition but if anyone can find a way it’ll be Apple.

  39. Of course, better quality watches are more complex. What I meant was the idea of wristwatches is nothing new. No matter what you pay for better quality it still just tells time (maybe the date, maybe when a certain time occurs, etc.)

    A Rolex doesn’t cost more because it tells the time better, you’re paying for the status. And I don’t feel the Apple Watch Edition, with the same design and functionality of more affordable Apple Watches, offers much higher status. It will have the same build quality and functionality as the Apple Watch Sport. For that matter, any Apple Watch will confer higher status simply because it’s an Apple product.

  40. Neither would I normally, but I think the actual patent explaining the process is an exception to the rule.

  41. Well, now we know. Apple found a way to make cheaper 18k gold and they’re passing the savings on to their shareholders.

  42. Being that I am a shareholder, I can’t say that’s bad for me. Disappointing, though. However, from the post-chatter, I am under the impression Apple Watch Edition uses a conventional alloy, not the composite.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *