On the iOS storage lawsuit

There’s been a lot of discussion about the lawsuit alleging that Apple is somehow defrauding its customers by selling a 16 Gig phone, which yields about 12 Gigs of usable space.

First off, take a look at the image in this post from last January.

Notice that of all the devices tested (the iPhone 6 and 6 Plus were not born yet), Apple provides the most consumer-usable storage.

Apple’s more affordable (relatively) iPhone, the 5c, is the most generous of the 16GB phones we’re recently tested, giving you 12.6GB of memory (79%) to play with. Meanwhile Google’s new Nexus 5, which runs on the Android operating system like the S4,, is relatively bloatware free with 12.28GB (77%) of usable space. The iPhone 5s is in bronze position, providing 12.2GB (76%) of usable storage.

Macworld, along with a number of others, called the lawsuit frivolous, dumb.

iOS 8 has had its share of problems, and now we can throw one more on the pile: a lawsuit. Two plaintiffs have filed a suit claiming their 16GB iPhones and iPads don’t actually come with 16GB of storage, and iOS 8 takes up too much space—and Apple should make that clearer, in case we are all idiots who don’t get that operating systems do use storage.

Kirk McElhearn takes a counter position:

The lawsuit also highlights the fact that iOS 8 takes up substantially more space than iOS 7, saying, “Plaintiff upgraded to iOS 8 with the belief that the upgrade would not substantially inhibit his available storage capacity. Defendant did not disclose in conjunction with upgrades to iOS 8 the additional storage capacity that would be consumed by the upgrade.” And, later, “Apple fails to disclose that upgrading from iOS 7 to iOS 8 will cost a Device user between 600 MB and 1.3 GB of storage space – a result that no consumer could reasonably anticipate.”

I agree that Apple should warn users about how much space the new OS will take up, perhaps stating that it will use X GB more than the previous version, or explain that if the current amount of free space is X GB, after the upgrade it will only by Y GB.

The space problem is compounded as there are more and larger displays for iOS devices. Since apps you install contain all the graphics for all available devices, they are getting bigger and bigger. It would make sense for iTunes – or iOS devices – to only install the graphics that specific devices need. This said, I understand why Apple does not do this. If you download an app to an older iPhone, then transfer the purchase to iTunes to later use on a larger device, the transferred app won’t have all the elements the larger device needs. Nevertheless, Apple could fix this, with a system that downloads all the app’s assets after you transfer the purchase.

Should Apple offer some options to allow you to eliminate wasted space? That would certainly help.

Should they be legally required to? Of course not.

Should all phone vendors do a better job of letting potential buyers know about the hazards of buying a device with a smaller memory footprint? Again, that would certainly help.

Should they be legally required to? There’s the rub.



27 thoughts on “On the iOS storage lawsuit”

  1. For me the problem is not about wrong claims. I don t think anyone really knows that 16G or 64G mean in terms of data or what you can put in it in an accurate way.

    What s really missing on Apple side is a simple notification mechanism that alerts you, just like the battery, when your memory is getting filled at X % and getting close to full. You could then decided how to best use and manage your memory resources to which Apple provide a wide range of options from iCloud extra storage to offloading photos to more…

    That would fix most of the key use cases i think many consumers have with their phone.

  2. And lets not forget the infamous “Other” category that takes up increasingly more memory as time goes on. Apple gives no way to purge it or even a clear explanation of what it is. Naturally, this is where they’re hiding the size of the OS.

  3. I swear there’s got to be a class taught at most law schools about “Best Practices for Suing Apple.” Basically, find a pain point among all consumer devices in a category, then sue Apple for not fixing it.

  4. As I have been saying, Apple should install iOS on a dedicated chip or partition that is invisible to the user and advertise the actual amount of content space as “True Storage.”
    http://www.loopinsight.com/2014/11/12/the-real-usable-space-of-an-ios-device/#comment-1689475855
    This would serve multiple purposes: 1) address this lawsuit. 2) maintain an area for iOS update downloads, so it will “just work.” 3) give Apple yet another marketing advantage over their rivals. Legally, this is not required, but the advantages outweigh the costs, which are meager for Apple but would be more costly for rivals.

  5. It’s not just the unused graphics that take up extra space. The binaries also are getting bigger and bigger. My release builds contain three architectures per binary (armv7, armv7s and arm64).

  6. I like the idea, but I’m not sure it would work. In the race to be the thinnest, adding another chip wouldn’t help. And a hidden partition would affect the amount of RAM they could advertise. If Apple were to hide 4GB on a 64GB iPhone for the OS and call it a 60GB model so you get all the RAM you paid for, the average consumer would go for the 64GB Samsung Galaxy that has more memory. Basically, none of them can be honest about usable RAM unless all of them are.

    What may have helped people thinking iOS8 got bigger than iOS 7 would have been not adding new apps to iOS 8 (like Tips and Health) and just making them available in the App Store, like they do with iLife. And what if you were only prompted to download Newsstand or Game Center when you bought a magazine or a game instead of preinstalling them? Or how about letting me delete the Stocks app? There’s plenty they could do in software to help the situation.

  7. Added SSD (not RAM) would not affect thickness. Apple fits a 128GB NAND chip in the same space as a 16GB chip, so they could easily add 8GB of space (not 4GB, because that wasn’t enough for the iOS 8 update). Adding a chip might require added footprint space, not thickness, which I admit might be a problem except Apple just increased the footprint of their iPhones. Regardless, it has no effect on thickness.

    As for the competition, do a search on “64GB Samsung Galaxy” and let me know how that works out for you. Apple’s only real competition is at the 16GB level, and this is why marketing this as “True Storage” is important. Samsung and others can still legally advertise 16GB, but Apple can explain that only the iPhone has “True Storage” where you get what is advertised. That’s Apple’s 12GB TrueStorage vs. Samsung’s 16GB advertised/8GB actual storage.

    As for removing apps, even removing all the extraneous apps would free up maybe half a GB.

  8. “Added SSD (not RAM) would not affect thickness. Apple fits a 128GB NAND chip in the same space as a 16GB chip, so they could easily add 8GB of space (not 4GB, because that wasn’t enough for the iOS 8 update)”

    Except no one actually makes 128+8, or even 16+8 NAND Flash chips (they’re not called SSD…) so Apple would have to create them, plus the factories to make them.

    Manufacturers produce memory chips in powers of 2, so the next step up from 16 is 32 and 128 is 256. But there are NO single chip 2048Mbit (256MB) Flash solutions available – 1024Mbit is currently the maximum density.

    Not so “easily” now is it…

  9. Another thing they could do is only sell 16Gb phones to developers, but make 32GB the base storage.

  10. As if we didn’t know any of this if we aren’t complete idiots. New operating systems are bigger? No! You don’t say! That they take up space on the hard drive? No! You don’t say!

    The phone has 16 gigs of space. Literally. You can sue for that? I doubt it.

    Apple does warn you that it requires a specific amount of space to install iOS 8. What part of that warning isn’t a tip-off that you’re: 1) Running out of space, and 2) The OS must be bigger.

    As for the mysterious “other” in the space consumed, that’s no doubt some proprietary stuff they don’t want to talk about. It would be nice to know what it is, but I suspect it’s not something you can remove anyway, even if you know what it is.

    Sure, Apple could be more clear about this. I’m betting they will be. Without the customer being treated as if they are the idiots they are.

  11. Connotatively, no. SSDs are generally flash memory in a box. Naked chips are PCIe SSDs. The kind they put in most Macs nowadays. What goes in phones is not called SSDs. They don’t have PCI busses. Such usage would be confusing.

  12. On Apple’s publicity they do not refer to the size as storage. They refer to it as capacity. A 16Gb iPhone has a total capacity of 16Gb not 16Gb of storage space. The misconception is on the side of the purchaser.

  13. ” The misconception is on the side of the purchaser.”
    Nope.

    The deliberate misconception is on the side of the lawyers.

  14. And ignore companies and products that have far, far worse stats in this regard (Surface, anyone?) but won’t ever generate a lawsuit because no one cares about hose products or companies.

  15. That sounds like a bad idea to me. Let’s say Apple advertises a 64GB iPhone. It’s actually 72GB (they managed to get 72GB somehow), with 8GB devoted to storage of the current and future OSes. (I’m just picking numbers here.)

    But the current OS only uses, say, 4GB. So now Apple has 4GB to spare. Do they offer it to the user or sit on it? If they just sit on it, it’s an extra cost to Apple (and their users) for memory nobody can use for years. Some of those devices will be recycled before more storage is needed. If they offer it to users, the next OS upgrade is going to reduce the capacity of the device.

    Now that’s flash forward three years. The last update to this hardware takes 9GB. What do they do now? If they don’t drop support for that hardware, they’re now (finally) dropping capacity.

  16. Xcode’s default is not to build armv7s anymore.

    I know, I know. Just saying. 🙂 I think they saw this was becoming a problem, too. But I’d rather have them deliver different apps that Apple constructs automatically from the build I give them that contains all architectures.

  17. This is why they only advertise the actual content space (“TrueStorage” or whatever). This eliminates any buyer confusion over what they actually get. Yes, there is more storage in the device, but only the content space is user-accessible. Tell the buyer exactly what they can use instead of letting them figure it out for themselves.

    As for the amount needed, the space reserved for the OS should be for both the OS and updates. Contrary to exaggerated reports, the iOS 8 update did not require more than 8GB, nor should an update ever require more than that. As I previously pointed out in the linked comment (and repeatedly do so), Apple ships the low-end iPhone with 8GB of storage and always deliver at least the next major update to it. 8GB is a hard limit already set a year in advance.

    Furthermore, 8GB is the stated minimum free space required to update to
    OS X Mavericks and Yosemite. If the iOS engineers cannot keep their
    update requirements below OS X requirements, they need to try harder.

    This space will be in use on a regular basis. There have already been several updates to iOS 8, most of them minor but all require download space. Regular updates that do not require users to delete videos/photos/apps should be part of the iPhone experience.

  18. You can sue for pretty much anything.

    You just can’t win.

    (On “Other”, people have, IIRC, determined that it’s mostly things like streaming cache.

    Apple’s flaw there is not letting people clear that sort of thing manually, more than anything else.)

    (Christ, next people will be suing Ford for advertising a 17 gallon [e.g.] fuel tank that only has 16.5 gallons of usable capacity, exactly as every car maker has done for the history of cars…)

  19. Tell the buyer exactly what they can use instead of letting them figure it out for themselves.

    yes but as he said — that is a variable. if you sell a 64GB device today and the OS only uses 4gb, it’s “TrueStorage” is 60. great. but in two years the OS takes up 6GB, so now the device is a 58GB device? that doesnt make any sense.

    what youre referring to is available space. available space changes depending on the software. theres no magic way around that.

  20. That is not the idea being argued or promoted. My idea is to add a dedicated partition or disk for iOS, which adds storage space to the device, so the total onboard is higher but only the content space is advertised as “TrueStorage.” Thus, when you buy a 16GB iPhone, you will get 16GB of storage. The separate partition or disk for iOS and updates is not user-accessible and never even mentioned. It is a physical addition to the device. This is why Steven mentions 72GB total and the “wasted” space on the OS partition. It is not something that Apple would implement retroactively, but it would address those three items in my initial comment going forward.

  21. A part of me agrees with these folks. Apple has bloated up iOS with language support that we don’t all need, with tones many folks never use. They keep including weather, stocks etc when there’s a ton of better free apps in the store. They baked in podcasts, ibooks and this new tips app. All of these things have made iOS bigger than it needs to be. Instead of coming up with systems to make it DLC.

    they have done the similar things with not having DLC in things like Pages, so we can download the templates when we actually need them and requiring an app for installing 3rd party keyboards. plus by not making their iOS apps DLC friendly they prevent the use of 3rd party templates, themes for iMovie, loop sets for garageband etc. Which would increase the creation side of iOS devices.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *