There’s been a lot of discussion about the legal implications of the recent move by CVS and Rite Aid to drop support for Apple Pay. This quote from a Reuters article clarified the point:
Antitrust experts said CVS and Rite Aid have the right to drop a vendor if they believe they can save money by going around the credit card companies and Apple, both of which will take a piece of the action.
But they could run into antitrust trouble if they coordinated on dropping Apple Pay and Google Wallet or if someone else, perhaps a person working with CurrentC, organized their decision to drop Apple and Google’s payment services.
“If I was a regulator, I would want to take a look at that,” said Peter Carstensen, who teaches antitrust at the University of Wisconsin Law School.
As I read this, antitrust would be an issue if a requirement was placed on CVS, Rite Aid, and other members of the MCX consortium to drop support for Apple Pay. In other words, no problem if CVS and Rite Aid independently decided to drop Apple Pay support.
But is that what happened here? What caused them both to drop Apple Pay? Was it a contractual requirement? Was there an email that went out from MCX to the exchange merchants laying out some rule requiring them to block Apple Pay?
I think it’s important to remember that these guys are talking anti-trust about a service that doesn’t even exist yet! Beyond that, this whole thing is about a consortium of merchants trying to break the stranglehold of three, but mostly just two, companies that control the payment card industry. DoJ and/or FTC have to really ask if it is really anti-trust when one group of companies is trying to break the monopolistic power of another group of companies? Finally, there’s nothing illegal about exclusive agreements (cf NFL and Bose). Rite Aid and CVS turned off their Apple Pay because they, likely, were contractually obligated to do so as part of their MCX membership. I believe Dekkar Davidson when he says that there is no “fine” to leave the consortium, but I also believe that leaving would mean that doing so involves forfeiting the, allegedly $300K-$500K, ‘buy-in.’ So Rite Aid and CVS have significant reasons to meet their, supposed, contractual obligations, for now at least.
I could very well be wrong. I’m not a lawyer, and this may indeed be anti-trust or monopoly, or collusion or whatever. But the fact is this, it’s taken regulators FIVE YEARS to go after AT&T for selling “unlimited data” that is in fact limited, by any definition of the word. If the government prevails and forces AT&T to, you know, accept and abide by the dictionary definition of a word, then I’ll have some confidence that they’ll go after and prevail over a company that surely has extremely deep pockets and platoons of talented lawyers who have vetted every facet of it’s existence in a matter of highly esoteric and somewhat unsettled law.
Agree mostly with what you say, except $300k-$500k is hardly “significant” to either of those companies. It takes CVS under 2 minutes to earn $500k in revenue.
I tend to agree, but without more (Hell—any!) hard information we’re all just guessing. That being said, I think that CVS and Rite Aid have taken WAY more than $300-$500K in damage to their brands, so the forfeiture has to be bigger, there are other considerations involved (e.g. once you leave you can’t come back), or maybe Dekker is flat-out lying (although that’s unlikely since CEOs generally just can’t lie about business matter). Bottom line, only the parties involved know the truth and, so far, none of them are saying much publicly.
It is not with respect to a service that is not out yet. the discussion is about blocking a service that is already out and members of the consortium working together or coordinating in some way to block Apple Pay.
I think of the (admittedly very small) population of stores that don’t even accept credit cards, that are cash only. They don’t take particular forms of payment, and no one thinks they’re colluding or monopolistic.
But that’s the weakest part of the argument. They didn’t just block Apple Pay. They also blocked Google Wallet and the-payment-system-formerly-known-as-ISIS. And they didn’t even block Google Wallet and TPSFKAI, they stopped using any and all NFC-based payment systems. Hard to imagine these fairly conservative companies doing that if they were on any kind of shaky legal ground.
Neither “collusion” nor “monopolies” are inherently illegal. It’s what you’re colluding about or doing as a monopoly that gets you in trouble.
Yes, the reason all these stores disabled NFC in order to block Apple Pay and Google Wallet is because of requirements of their MCX membership to not accept any mobile payment solution other than that developed by MCX. Retailers face fines from MCX if they do accept competing mobile payment options. This has been reported widely, here is one such report: http://www.macrumors.com/2014/10/29/mcx-retailer-currentc-exclusivity/
“This has been reported widely” And that makes it true? Dude the site has the word RUMORS in its title! While I’m not saying they’re wrong, the reality is that the CEO of a company can’t go out in public and make knowingly untrue statements, or at least there are serious implications if they do. Dekkers Davidson said flat-out in public that there’s no fine, so I tend to believe there’s no fine. There may be some other kind of adverse financial effect to companies that leave the consortium, but, unless Dekkers Davidson is a self-destructive sociopath, there is no “fine.”
Hey if these MCX retailers want to stop taking credit cards completely they’re free to do so. But they aren’t. They are working together to specifically block services that compete with MCX’s own. Especially when we’re talking about businesses that should otherwise be competing for customer attention, that is the definition of “collusion”.
If you’d read the post from the “rumors” site you’d see that MCX confirmed that it’s retailers are required to back CurrentC exclusively. While they did not confirm whether there is a fine they did say that retailers are free to leave MCX without penalty (which is nice of them). So If you’re an MCX member retailer and you want to accept Apple Pay and Google Wallet you MUST leave MCX and lose whatever benefits of membership there are.
I’m amazed to see so many defenders of MCX here. What argument can you make that having a bunch of competing retailers working together to limit customer choice in payments in order to bolster their own self-serving option is fair or should be encouraged? These guys aren’t going to stop taking credit cards altogether so spare me the “breaking the stranglehold of the credit card companies” rap.
I have read them, and I understand them. My point is, somebody is wrong about “the fines.” It’s either those unnamed sources or the CEO who just publicly put his reputation on the line. Who are you going to believe?
As for “So If you’re an MCX member retailer and you want to accept Apple Pay and Google Wallet you MUST leave MCX and lose whatever benefits of membership there are.” Really? You’re sure of that? You’ve read the entire MCX member agreement? Ah, well please enlighten us as to the other terms. How much is the buy-in? There is one, right? Is the price the same for everyone? If not, who pays more?
The language of MCX’s own blog post make it pretty clear:
“When merchants choose to work with MCX, they choose to do so exclusively and we’re proud of the long list of merchants who have partnered with us. Importantly, if a merchant decides to stop working with MCX, there are no fines.”
You can either work with MCX exclusively OR you can leave MCX. I’m not sure why you are fixating on membership dues and the like. As an MCX retailer you either offer CurrentC to the exclusion of other mobile wallets or you leave MCX. The only denial of fines is that there are no fines for leaving MCX. MCX has not so far commented on what would happen for a retailer that wanted to offer both CurrentC AND Google Wallet/Apple Pay.
Your zeal for defending what is clearly collusion to limit customer choice for the gain of a group of retailers at the expense of privacy and security strikes me as odd to say the least. If CurrentC is a great system then it should win out over Apple Pay/Google Wallet on its own. Funny how capitalist organizations want to subvert the free market in this case. Typically only inferior products require protectionist regulations to help them along.
Indeed. If Apple was held culpable for collusion when they were trying to fight against Amazon’s arguably anti-competitive behavior, why wouldn’t Rite Aid/CVS/MCX also be culpable?
im not reading a zeal for defending collusion in his comments. im reading someone pointing out that some of whats been reported appears inaccurate. doing so doesnt make something anti apple or pro MCX.
I’m not defending MCX, unless saying they’re not doing anything illegal, or even wrong, is defending them. You realize you’re faulting one group of big, and smaller, businesses for trying to pay less money to a small group of very large businesses, right? Personally, I don’t care who wins the MCX vs Credit Card Companies fight, but I also know that it’s not a MCX vs Apple fight.
who is defending MCX? i see some people questioning the collusion angle (whom i happen to disagree with), but that doesnt make them defenders or anti apple.
rite aid & cvs wouldnt be culpable if they acted independently. the possible collusion would be against MCX for orchestrating it. thats what they claimed about apple, that they orchestrated it. individual players in the marketplace are supposed to operate independently. they can all make the same decision if it happens organically, but they cant move to block other players in the free market as a team.
A service that doesn’t exist, but has an app and has already been breached.
It’s more involved than that. You can “collude” all you want if what you’re colluding about is legal, in that case it’s usually called “collaboration.” Apple and the big 5 publishers colluded to price-fix, which the DoJ considered a different matter. I’m not sure if, in retrospect, a lot of people in the DoJ feel so great about that decision in light of the stuff Amazon has pulled since.
You are just making the argument for antitrust investigation.
It’s not an issue of deciding to block a certain payment form. It’s not the issue of , say McDonalds, deciding one day to stop accepting all forms of credit cards and only accepting cash and MCX. That is fine.
The problems comes on when, in this example, McDonalds decides to go a step further and contacts Wendy’s, Burger King and Taco Bell and tells them what a great idea it is and they all collectively decide to follow suit.
For there to be collusion there has to be organization and agreement. Remember when Apple was found guilty of colluding with book publishers. The irony is that they perhaps didnt since it was the same terms they have used for years with other media. But a single email saying ‘other people have agreed to these terms’ was considered enough to damn them. well at least until the appeals are heard.
on the flip, most places that don’t take credit cards are Mom and Pop places. They are by their nature independent and thus it wasnt the orders of the great leaders of the Mom and Pop Shop Association barring them from taking credit cards. But that is supposedly exacting what the MCX contracts did. Sure they say now there are no fines and anyone can leave but you can bet they will be out the half mil they paid to get in if they do either. And that demand to not use other services could be just as much collusion as Apple ‘encouraging’ publishers to make all vendors use Apple style terms
And, given the size of these retailers, it is quite likely that in certain areas of the country their sales of certain goods (e.g. Rx) could represent a near monopoly which would warrant stricter scrutiny.
This is a good point.
In the end I think the answer is to fire it a bit more grassroots. Make sure folks are fully educated about this system and things like this early hack (which will only get worse when millions of bank acounts are in there) and let the buyers decide. If someone chooses to put in that info and use that system they have no one to blame but themselves if it gets hacked and the info stolen.
Those of us that dont like companies telling us we can’t use things like Google Wallet and Apple Pay can still use our old style credit cards or we can not shop in such places. If enough folks make the decision on our own to personally boycott companies that bar NFC the companies might change their minds. And they might win us back, or not
But the IRS is skeptical of their reasons for not taking credit cards. Though I understand why. My brother the locksmith doesn’t take American Express because their card fees are 2 or more percent higher than Visa and Mastercard. He loves cash, but he knows he can’t do business without taking credit cards. Apple Pay is just another form of a system he already uses.
But, as Martin rightly pointed out, your analysis of whether reports about fines are accurate or not is, itself, not accurate.
There is nothing the CEO has said or blogged that is inconsistent with fines being levied on businesses that are part of the MCX group and violate the covenant against exclusivity.
It seem quite likely that, if it is a covenant in the contract, then there would be enforcement mechanisms built in as well.
Whether the covenant and those enforcement schemes create antitrust issues is a separate issue and one that seems to me to be quite problematic.
You have Walmart, Target, RiteAid and CVS all agreeing to prohibit acceptance of a form of credit card transaction that has no higher cost than any other credit card transaction to facilitate creation of an exclusive mobile payment option.
I would think it very interesting to see what % of the Rx market they have in various geographic areas of the country. That, in and of itself, may be a trigger for stricter scrutiny of this practice.
You’re very nail-on-head with this one Martin. Right on!
We are certainly working without real information, and the DOJ are the very folks who get that information buy opening an investigation (not necessarily pressing charges on anything yet — just getting ahold of contracts and emails).
There has been a petition on WhiteHouse.gov asking President Obama to order the DOJ to open such an investigation to find out the truth.
https://petitions.whitehouse.gov/petition/order-doj-investigation-merchant-commerce-exchange-facilitating-anti-competitive-collusion-among/Ms9VCP9y
Yup…. Folks should sign the petition if they haven’t already:
https://petitions.whitehouse.gov/petition/order-doj-investigation-merchant-commerce-exchange-facilitating-anti-competitive-collusion-among/Ms9VCP9y
If Apple and Amazon made a deal that neither would sell Hachette books in order to drive the publisher out of business then that would be colluding.
It seems to me that about 50 retailers made a deal to try to exclude Visa and MasterCard from mobile payments (which is the future of payments) in order to drive them out of business.
This would be like Apple and Amazon saying that they would carry Hachette’s print books (as if Apple carried books in its retail store), BUT would exclude Hachette’s ebooks from their sales.
Either one of them independently doing this is fine. But if Apple and Amazon agreed on doing this together or through an intermediary trying to organize them to do it then it becomes collusion.
That is the problem with MCX. It is an intermediary that is also owned by the participating merchants.
Not just collectively decide, but sign contracts with penalties if they fail to live up to the agreement. I really want to see those contracts and that’s why I want a DOJ investigation to bring them into public scrutiny. The consumer is being disadvantaged here by this collusion and that should not be allowed in the US economy.
I know I have said it before on here, but please sign the petition at WhiteHouse.gov if you have not done so already:
https://petitions.whitehouse.gov/petition/order-doj-investigation-merchant-commerce-exchange-facilitating-anti-competitive-collusion-among/Ms9VCP9y
The part that’s baffling to me is that these companies still take credit cards!? Why not allow users to continue using a credit card via ApplePay or Google Wallet? It doesn’t make any sense AT ALL, especially since the infrastructure is already in place. The NFC terminals that are in the stores work with ApplePay without needing to change a thing. In fact, it took more effort to deny use than to continue to allow it.
And to top it off… ApplePay transaction fees are even lower than using an actual card, because the chances of fraud are dramatically lowered.
There was also a petition to build a Death Star. I think a DoJ investigation is only slightly more likely.
I’d have to disagree. This sounds too much like the same argument used to frame Apple in the DoJ ebooks fiasco.
The companies here are members of a consortium. They are going to be talking to each other. And there is no way two retailers like this could by themselves move the needle in dominating the retail market in any case.
They may be slimeballs putting the customer dead last but they are not wrong to talk and end up doing something like this at the same time. It makes sense to do it at THIS time because this is when Apple Pay was released.
I’m loathe to use BI as support, but it’s better than trying to prove a negative. So here goes:
“During a news conference, MCX CEO Dekkers Davidson shot down an earlier report from The New York Times that said MCX members would suffer fines or penalties if they accepted Apple Pay.
‘There are no fines to MCX merchants,’ Davidson said. ‘There’s nothing in the structure that would have us do that. It’s simply not true. There are no fines.'” http://www.businessinsider.com/mcx-open-to-apple-pay-2014-10#ixzz3HkR2rJsc
“There are no fines.” is pretty unequivocal. Yeah, there’s some room for weaseling, but less than from unnamed sources. As for “enforcement mechanisms”, the best one is that if you don’t stay exclusive with CurrentC, you’re out of MCX. If the whole point of membership is avoiding interchange fees, accepting a payment that has interchange fees AND gets you booted from the system that lets you avoid them is it’s own enforcement mechanism.
I also am suspicious of BI, but reading the whole article it does seem that the CEO (and subsequent talk with the COO) hasn’t left MCX a whole lot of wiggle room for fines.
Of course, as you note, the real enforcement mechanism is the forced drop out if you violate exclusivity.
And, regardless, the enforcement mechanism is not really germane to the antitrust issue.
Still, thank you for clarifying and providing a relatively clear citation for your position.
I will amend my arguments because of it.
But any time there is a meeting of competitors they have to be very, very careful about what they are or are not discussing as the potential for restraint of trade allegations/realities is right there.
As for these retailers dominating a retail market, it really depends on what the relevant retail market is. Is it specific products in a specific geographic locale?
As I noted in earlier posts, it is not at all out of the realm of possibility that the MCX members may have 80%+ shares of certain goods in certain (particularly rural) communities.
I’ve been mentioning this for a while. Every time I post about it on macrumors, or on my twitter feed, I get shot down.. But, to me it’s clear: there is something funny going on when all these competitors are all working together.
If it looks like a duck, smells like a duck, talks like a duck, and colludes like a duck, then, maybe it is a duck….
Fair enough.
The irony is that I think Apple could really shift the paradigm seismically if it took its overseas untaxed cash, created a Bermuda-based holding company, used that to buy a big national US bank, and then created its own payment system.
Even if it was only accepted in Apple Stores and iTunes it would make Apple 2-3% of the gross receipts of the most profitable retail chain and online music stores in the world. Not a small chunk of change.
My first thought about Apple Pay was that it could very well be the Motorola ROKR to a later financial services iPhone.
The only problem is that it isn’t illegal to be a duck. And when ducks are outlawed, only outlaws will be ducks.
2-3% less fraud/collection/bad debt/infrastructure/personnel costs. Plus diverted management attention, new security headaches, etc.
I prefer they stick to their knitting. YMMV
That’s certainly the conventional wisdom, and Apple indeed famously shies away from going, too far, from its areas of expertise. Still my rebuttal to that kind of thinking is:
“We’ve learned and struggled for a few years here figuring out how to make a decent phone,” he [Ed Cooligan, former and LAST, CEO of Palm Inc.] said. “PC guys are not going to just figure this out. They’re not going to just walk in.”
Yeah, talk about ‘putting the horse before the cart.’
But with phones, it was about computer hardware and software. Apple notably didn’t launch an MNVO or some sort of wide area wifi telecom alternative venture. They went with just the hardware and software. Kinda like they did with Apple Pay.
At the time of the iPhone launch, quite a few commentators were very disappointed because they were hoping the iPhone would disrupt the telecom market directly.
All valid points, and I’m the first to admit it’s unlikely at best. However I can’t help but think that if the right “hardware and software” idea occurred to someone in Cupertino so many of the pieces (e.g. tons of cash, extensive online/B&M retail network, loyal consumers, and a market ripe for an iPod/iTunes/iPhone-style disruption) for a next generation financial system seem to be “right there” for Apple. Apple Pay seems like the perfect low-risk, low-visibility training ground for the people who bring the AppleCard to market in 2019.
I agree to a certain point… However, there’s nothing wrong with these merchants getting together and forming a new payment system. (Bodies like this are formed all the time to develop standards.)
The only issue I foresee, is the use of an exclusionary agreement. If they honestly feel their system will win over consumers, then give them the choice and let them vote with their actions.
That’s a big issue. If they’re collaborating to use their combined dominance in one market (retail) to forcibly exert control over another market (mobile payments), they’re in serious trouble.
An Apple MNVO would be my idea of a great way to cut a lot of cords. If only.
It’s all too easy for weary, angry consumers to see every trade association as yet another AT&T/Verizon Mafia-like non-compete handshake while splitting territories.
It’s not necessarily about willful wrongdoing. It could simply be another example of delusional groupthink.
Yes, it’s a service that hasn’t yet been deployed, but it is certainly making its presence felt in the market, and having a notable effect upon consumer choice.