Samsung files appeal against first patent trial verdict

With surprising speed, Samsung has now officially filed a notice of appeal over the final judgement in the first Apple vs. Samsung patent trial from 2012. The last ruling in the case was handed down yesterday, when Judge Lucy Koh ruled in Samsung’s favor that sales injunctions on the products it was found guilty of infringing Apple patents with were not warranted in the interests of competition. Apple is likely to appeal that portion of Judge Koh’s rulings.

In the original trial (and the limited damages retrial), none of Samsung’s original counter-claims against Apple were given the time of day by the two juries in the case; all were dismissed due to prior art, while Apple won judgements against Samsung to the tune of nearly $1 billion in penalties against the Korean electronics firm (originally Apple was awarded just over $1.05 billion, but a portion of the damages was re-calculated in a juried damages retrial, with the result being $929 million instead).

Will this never end?



  • rattyuk

    “Will this never end?”

    Nope, QE and Samsung are just stringing it out as long as possible, ripping off whoever they want (not just Apple, they did it to Sony in the TV space and are doing it to Dyson in the vacuum cleaner space). Of course, in this particular case, Apple have very deep pockets. But it is pathetic.

    The S5 “innovations” That would be a gold color option and a fingerprint scanner… Why would they do that? (OK they also made it water resistant, just as Sony did in their last phone, too)