∞ Parting Macworld Expo thoughts: Wish you were here

Among all the things I heard at Macworld Expo this past week, absolutely the most banal, trite, idiotic, and pointless observation was, “This show isn’t the same without Apple.”

Of course it isn’t the same without Apple. We all knew it wouldn’t be the moment that Apple announced they were pulling out of the event. Apple thinks it’s grown out of needing to exhibit at Macworld Expo, so IDG World Expo, the show’s producers, needed to find a way to move beyond that.

I think they’ve done remarkably well, and I can’t wait to see what 2011 holds.

I got a lot out of my time at Macworld Expo

First, wearing my executive editor hat at The Loop, this show was a stunning success. I met with tons of great industry people – everyone from independent iPhone application developers, established “big name” companies, peripheral makers, distributors and others.

You may not see the evidence of that today, based on our headlines. That’s partly because there were, quite frankly, fewer big, breaking announcements than years past. But that’s also part of a longer-range focus from Jim Dalrymple and me to focus our attention more on meaningful news we can apply some context to for our readers.

But make no mistake: My time here will pay off in the days and weeks to come. Because I was able to meet with people and talk about things that I’ll be bringing to you when the time comes – important news that affects you, affects your business, and the way you use your Mac and other Apple devices.

In short, my time was spent communicating with a broad cross-section of the Apple ecosystem – Mac, iPhone, iPod and soon iPad. Plus there were thousands of attendees, checking out their wares from the show floor, attending conference sessions, incredibly in-depth pro tools tracks, user conferences, birds of a feather meetings and more.

And that, right there, is what makes Macworld Expo such a crucially important event for the entire Apple ecosystem. There’s no other event like it, anywhere.

Not my best show ever

Late on Saturday evening, with the show receding rapidly into our rear view mirror, Shawn King of Your Mac Life and I compared notes outside of our favorite local late-night watering hole.

Shawn asked me to apply a letter grade to rate the show, and my answer was C. That bears an explanation though, so please stick with me.

Shawn’s eyebrows went way up – perhaps even more remarkable, because after a visit to a master barber Shawn makes an annual pilgrim to every year during Macworld Expo, his eyebrows were almost the only hair left on his head.

Shawn said he was surprised to hear me rate this year’s show that low, because others had been averaging about a B rating – not bad compared to some years that Apple has exhibited, I assure you. And if you don’t know Shawn, let me just say that he’s not the guy to blow smoke up your butt – he’ll tell it like it is, for better or worse.

My C grade was mainly ruminating on my own performance. From my perspective, it was simply a matter of poor time management – I didn’t have anyone but myself to blame.

Well, I’ll blame Jim Dalrymple a little bit, because he stayed home and didn’t chaperone me, and believe me I could have used it.

I didn’t have enough hours in the day to do everything I needed to, And in typical fashion, even with a smaller expo hall than last year, I didn’t have nearly enough time on the show floor.

Was my experience typical? For someone with a badge that said “Expo Only,” chances are no. If that’s all you came to the show for, you found a much smaller event. But Macworld Expo is much bigger than just the show floor. There are a lot of activities, a lot of events, and there’s an immense amount of added value if you look around.

We hope you’ll join us next time

Here’s the bottom line: Macworld Expo isn’t, and never has been, Apple’s event. It’s our event. The users. The people. Each and every person who walked in the door. If you weren’t there, you missed out. And it’s our loss, too, because the show was diminished without you here.

But you know what? Those of us who were here had a great time without you.

We miss you, and we hope you’ll come back. We’ll have an even better time together in 2011. I promise.



  • http://twitter.com/Moeskido @Moeskido

    I knew better than to torture myself by looking at the conference and training schedules for a show I couldn't attend. Way too much interesting stuff I couldn't take part in, but I have hopes for next year.

  • Jay

    JIm stayed home. And so did I. But why did Jim and I have to miss out on what seems to have been a great event? I sent Paul Kent an email last year (unanswered, of course) suggesting that for those of us with limited time and/or budgets, he should consider Virtual Macworld: an integrated companion virtual show attendance 'track' made possible by such vendors as Unisfair ( http://www.unisfair.com/ ) and others. We could attend streamed audio (maybe video) of keynotes and conference sessions…participate with questions in the conf sessions…hob nob with other virtual and socially networked attendees and vendors, view special virtual vendor booths…in short, everything that distance learning and webcasting allows. And how about small independent developers and vendors? They could participate virtually, too. Many can't afford to exhibit in person, but it would be a different situation if they could do so virtually. Maybe in-person attendees would get a free or discounted 'admittance' to Virtual Macworld, to complement their in-person schedules. They could multi-task while in a session, having lunch, or just too beat to pund the show floor.

    I'd be willing to pay nearly same amount to get the near-experience and save air, lodging and food expenses. It doesn't have to (nor could it) provide the best of why people go, namely, tactile meet and greet, hands on demos, purchase discounted stuff, swag, etc. Those who live nearby, and those who have the money/reason to travel there to attend, will continue to attend. But a whole new revenue stream could open up for IDG/Macworld if virtual attendance was built into the mix of offerings for 2011 and beyond. And it sure would be great for those of us who, for one reason or another, couldn't physically make it to the show.

  • http://www.facebook.com/flargh Peter Cohen

    A virtual Macworld Expo show pass definitely has some merits, though I don't think it would even come close to the richer experience you get in face-to-face interactions with vendors, colleagues and trainers.

    • Jay

      I wouldn't expect it to be a replacement but, really, more of a complement to the main in-person event. Anyone who has ever done distance learning or webcasts knows the limitations of virtual participation. I think many time/finance-challenged Macworld attendees like me would be eager to accept those limitations in order to receive a virtual version of the knowledge and collateral dispensed at the conference sessions. ANd with a social network component, it could be a different but still fun and useful experience.

      As a follow up to my post, Paul Kent graciously responded yesterday; the Loop has readers in high places :-) . I got three things from his reply: 1) He is a man who listens to the community all year round, and truly cares what we think. 2) IDG has looked into a virtual component but thinks it is still a bit premature–a view I am not sure I agree with, at least from an attendee's pov; and 3) After I hit the 'submit' button on my post, I realized I inadvertently 'dissed' Paul by insinuating he never replies to emails (which he obviously did with me, and says it is one of his policies to try to do so with others). In my mind, I was thinking that when I sent him the email last year, it was right after Macworld so of course he didn't respond…he'd be too busy. I expressed that badly. My apologies, publicly, to Paul. He is one of the good guys in our community and I disparaged that reputation.:)

  • Ashley

    Peter,

    I'd love to get an audio recording, video, notes or anything from the presentation you did on Friday at 10am.
    I just couldn't make it there this year but plan on it next year. Anywhere we can see any of that stuff?:D

    • http://www.facebook.com/flargh Peter Cohen

      Ashley:

      The iPhone marketing and bizdev symposium was an all-day event – it ran from 10 to 5 PM, and it was something that attendees had to pay extra to go to, so I don't think IDG will be releasing it publicly. Sorry!